Carbon capture and utilization (CCU) presents investors and project developers with a fundamental trade-off: the pathways that can absorb the most CO2 tend to produce the lowest-value products, while the highest-value products serve markets too small to move the emissions needle. A technical study by the IEAGHG, which assessed commodities across four CCU categories, found that the potential scale for deployment was much greater for fuels and building materials than for chemicals, whose existing markets are orders of magnitude smaller. Meanwhile, most chemicals and fuels routes were found to be considerably more expensive than conventional fossil-based production. Understanding this inverse relationship between market scale and product value is the starting point for any CCU investment decision.

Understanding Carbon Capture Utilization (CCU) Pathways

CCU refers to converting captured CO2 into valuable products rather than storing it underground. According to a World Economic Forum report launched in September 2025, emerging CCU pathways are concentrated in three areas: fuels, chemicals, and building materials. The report notes that fuels alone represent 11.5 million tonnes per annum of the 15 million tonnes of CO2 utilization in development by 2030, and it argues that investment diversification beyond fuels will be critical for CCU to reach its full economic and emissions-abatement potential.

The scale of the challenge is considerable. The same World Economic Forum report found that planned projects cover just 6% of what is needed by 2040 to meet global climate targets. This gap frames the strategic question for decision-makers: not whether CCU works, but which pathway offers the best combination of economic viability and meaningful CO2 utilization in a given context.

The IEAGHG study, which assessed mitigation potential, market uptake potential, and technical scalability across CCU categories, provides the quantitative backbone for comparing these routes. Almost all CCU routes showed potential for lower life cycle emissions per tonne of product compared to their conventional counterfactuals, though the study also identified trade-offs including high energy demand, additional land use, and increased water consumption alongside co-benefits such as reuse of waste residues and improved product properties.

Comparative Analysis of CCU Pathways: Fuels, Chemicals, and Building Materials

The table below synthesizes findings from the IEAGHG study and the Oil and Gas Climate Initiative (OGCI), which assessed utilization pathways for 2040 based on technological readiness, market interest, and estimated market size. The pattern that emerges is consistent: high-scale pathways struggle with cost or value, while high-value pathways are constrained by market size.

Comparative Trade-offs of CCU Pathways
DimensionCO2-to-FuelsCO2-to-ChemicalsCO2-to-Building Materials
Market Potential (Scale)Very large: annual abatement greater than 1 GtCO2-eq achievable for direct replacement "drop-in" fuels; 11.5 Mtpa CO2 in development by 2030Small: total mitigation potential limited to below 20 MtCO2-eq per year, with the exception of methanolLarge: annual abatement greater than 100 MtCO2-eq achievable; OGCI estimates construction aggregates alone at 0.5–2 Gt CO2 volume
Product Value / Cost CompetitivenessConsiderably more expensive than conventional fossil-based production routesHigher market value than building materials, but still considerably more expensive than fossil-based productionCan offer cost reductions, but low product value makes it hard to compete with very low-cost conventional aggregates
Key Cost DriversHigh energy requirements for green hydrogen feedstock, low yields, high catalyst costs, and CO2 feedstock cost and availabilitySame drivers as fuels: green hydrogen energy requirements, low yields, high catalyst costs, plus CO2 feedstock costsLow product value of aggregates; economics depend heavily on local construction markets and feedstock conditions
CO2 Sequestration PermanenceShort-lived: CO2 returns to the atmosphere when fuels are burnedVariable, depending on product lifetimeLongest-lived: potential for negative emissions when CO2 is sourced from direct air capture (DAC)

Three conclusions follow from this comparison. First, fuels offer the largest abatement opportunity—greater than 1 GtCO2-eq annually for drop-in fuels, per the IEAGHG study—but face persistent cost disadvantages against fossil alternatives. Second, chemicals command higher product values but are capped at below 20 MtCO2-eq per year of mitigation potential except for methanol, limiting their scalability. Third, building materials combine large volume potential with the possibility of cost reductions and, uniquely, negative emissions when paired with DAC, yet the low value of products like aggregates undermines the business case.

Key Economic Drivers for CCU Project Viability

The IEAGHG study identifies the dominant cost drivers for chemicals and fuels routes: high energy requirements for green hydrogen feedstock, low yields, and high catalyst costs. This means the economics of these pathways are effectively tethered to the price of low-carbon electricity. Regions with abundant, cheap renewable energy hold a structural advantage, because green hydrogen production—the upstream input for most CO2-to-fuels and CO2-to-chemicals processes—consumes the largest share of production costs.

The cost and availability of CO2 feedstock itself also play a crucial role. Whether CO2 comes from an industrial point source or from direct air capture changes both the cost structure and the emissions accounting: the IEAGHG study notes that CCU building materials sourced from DAC can achieve negative emissions, a property point-source CO2 cannot deliver.

Policy support is the third pillar. The World Economic Forum report argues that collaborative partnerships and more cohesive policies are needed to remove market barriers for CCU scaling, and that building confidence in the technology's abatement potential is key to scaling it up. For fuels and chemicals, which the IEAGHG found considerably more expensive than fossil-based routes, policy instruments that price the emissions advantage or subsidize production costs are often what determines whether a project closes its financing. Building materials, by contrast, compete on cost against very cheap conventional aggregates, so their viability depends more on procurement standards and construction market access than on energy prices.

Strategic Considerations for Investment and Application

For decision-makers, the comparative evidence suggests matching pathway to objective rather than seeking a single best option. An investor prioritizing maximum CO2 utilization volume would look to fuels or building materials, accepting either high production costs (fuels) or low product value (aggregates). One prioritizing revenue per tonne would look to chemicals, accepting a small addressable market. One prioritizing durable sequestration would look to building materials, particularly where DAC-sourced CO2 can deliver negative emissions.

Portfolio logic also applies. The World Economic Forum's finding that fuels dominate the project pipeline—11.5 of 15 Mtpa in development by 2030—while planned projects cover only 6% of what is needed by 2040 suggests both an execution gap and a concentration risk. Diversification across pathways hedges against the possibility that any single route fails to reach cost parity.

Finally, decision-makers should scrutinize life cycle claims. The OGCI's CCU report cautions about greenwashing risk in utilization claims, and the IEAGHG study notes that while almost all CCU routes showed lower life cycle emissions per tonne of product than their counterfactuals, trade-offs such as high energy demand, additional land use, and increased water consumption must be weighed. A fuels project powered by fossil-heavy electricity, for instance, could forfeit much of its claimed benefit.

Informing CCU Investment and Application Decisions

Investors and project developers should prioritize CCU pathways by carefully evaluating the trade-offs between market scale, product value, and CO2 sequestration permanence, aligning chosen pathways with specific economic objectives and regional advantages. The evidence supports a clear screening sequence: first establish the regional cost of low-carbon energy and CO2 feedstock, then match the pathway's cost structure to that advantage—energy-intensive fuels and chemicals where cheap renewables exist, building materials where construction demand and procurement policy reward low-carbon materials.

Successful CCU projects will demonstrate improved cost competitiveness against fossil-based alternatives, increased market adoption, and robust policy support, particularly in regions with favorable energy costs and infrastructure. Those three indicators—cost parity progress, adoption growth, and policy durability—are the measurable signals by which any chosen pathway should be judged as the 2030 development pipeline matures.

Sources